Crazy.Beautiful.Life

Editing Your Novel is Critical, But Man, Does It Suck

editing-rates

Last night, I put my novel on sale at Amazon, Barnes and Noble, and Kobo.  It was the completion of a four to five week process that started with a break up, and hopefully finishes with me becoming a best selling author.  (Ha!  In my dreams!)

One of the things I knew had to happen to my book before I published it was editing, because I have a tendency to switch tense and drop entire words out of sentences.  Self editing NEVER catches those kind of things, because I always knew what I was saying in my head.

So, I posted on here, and on facebook, about needing an editor for my novel.  I couldn’t pay them, but I could make sure their name was in the liner notes.  I got a couple bites, and began sharing my google doc to those who said they could help.

So the edits started… they came pouring in, and by Wednesday, I was practically ready to scrap the novel and start again.  You see, I had already ran through it for content multiple times, so almost every edit was:

“You forgot a word here.”

“Is this really the word you want to use?”

“Your tense in messed up.”

Every day I would log in to my email and find another batch of 40 or so edits to my novel, and I was starting to think that I was the most horrible writer in the history of writers.  In fact, yesterday morning, I almost unshared my document completely and scrapped the book.  Sure, I had already created the website and pimped it on twitter, but I couldn’t take another little ego blow like the comment box which was screaming at me, “You are horrible at this, why do you think you can even write a novel maggot?!”  (FYI – the comment box has a drill Sargent type voice.)

And it’s not like some miracle occurred where this feeling went away either.  Instead, I got an email from one of my editors, Terry, who said he was complete.  He was done.  He had finished.   All I had to do was make it through the last chapters of edits and my book would be complete, and finished.   When I finally reached the final edit, which required a total rewrite of the last paragraph of the book, I was shocked.  I had survived my first editing process.  The hell of being told the million tiny ways you suck was over.

Last night, I read through the final copy.  It was smoother, had less errors, and I knew that all the editing was worth it.  But man – it sucked.

I’ve submitted my novel to Barnes and Noble, Amazon and Kobo.  It will be available on Monday, October 15th exactly like I planned.   Now it’s onto the next book in the series.   Thank god you have writing time before you have to get edited again.

Have you ever had a novel edited?  How did you make it through the process?

  • Terry

    It was smoother, had less errors. [Consider "had fewer errors."]

    Sorry – habit :) Seriously, none of the edits were meant remotely in the spirit of “you suck” – just polishing the car so to speak. Good luck!!

    • http://www.howmanyfrogs.com/ Stephanie Dorman

      Haha, seriously, thank you so much Terry for editing. :) I never would have actually published it without you. :)

  • http://twitter.com/artyyah A.K.Andrew

    Interesting way of getting your novel edited for free. Sounds like it was really successful I’m in the middle of doing my second draft at the moment. Still in the enjoyment phase. Try me in a couple of months – my response might be different!

    • http://www.howmanyfrogs.com/ Stephanie Dorman

      Well, the good news is, you can always go back to the enjoyment phase, even if you get annoyed. There’s always another story to be written! :)

  • MaryBeth

    It’s rough but here’s the thing, all the books you find on the shelves in those stores have gone through SEVERAL editing processes. Nothing is perfect the first time through. Your draft is just to get the story out there. Editing is where you make it shiny and appealing to the reader. I saw a tweet yesterday from one my favorite authors, Libba Bray. She is working on a sequel to her new book The Diviners. It doesn’t seem to be going so well:

    libba bray ‏@libbabray
    Right now, DIVINERS #2 is so bad that it could only be IMPROVED by the addition of Ewoks. Them’s damning words.

    This is her 6th or 7th work being published and I’m pretty sure she’s been on the NYT Best sellers list. Even the professionals have shitty first drafts :P Don’t let it get to you!

    • http://www.howmanyfrogs.com/ Stephanie Dorman

      What’s amazing is that I started this never intending it to actually be read by ANYONE. Let alone… everyone.

      I think the first horrible review I get I might cry. LOL

  • http://twitter.com/SuziShumaker Suzi Shumaker

    I’ve been in the editing/revising/rewriting phase for MONTHS now and it will continue for several more months, with the help of paid editors. You’re lucky to have found volunteers and gotten through your edits so quickly – I’m so sick of my book!

    • http://www.howmanyfrogs.com/ Stephanie Dorman

      I’m willing to pass the good luck about editing forward if you want to have someone else check out your work. :) Sometimes all you need is a fresh pair of eyes.

      I also promise to write good things, not just edits in there. LOL

  • http://www.facebook.com/lizzyespy Elizabeth Espinosa

    How much time did you leave yourself between drafting and editing? I have no experience other than papers for school but I have heard good things about putting a month in between phases – you will catch so much more. Also, for spelling/grammatical errors in sentences, reading backwards sentence by sentence also helps because it forces you to slow down and actually read the sentence out of context. Reading naturally, your mind fills in the blanks and you never even realize you’re missing it. Just a couple tips :-)

  • http://twitter.com/sonja_rois Sonja Rois

    Editing really does suck. Not just for the writer, but the editor also. I have done both. I suffer from a form of dyslexia that puts words in the wrong place both when I write and when I speak. However, reading, I am fine. Because of this I cannot edit my own work, but apparently I’m great for doing so on other ppl’s work. Anyway, my point being, I HATE having to tell a friend about all the little tedious mess ups, or that they might want to rewrite something. Often a page can look like a see of red and that always makes me anxious to give it back to the person because I don’t want them to get frustrated over what could just be a lot of typos or misspellings. For myself, since I do edit others work, I understand that this is part of the process and I don’t let it discourage me. You still put out a novel in WAY less time than most (I’ve been working on my own book for going on 10 years now. A lot of that’s my fault though. It’s a time issue), I would suggest that you at least try to edit someone else’s work so you can better understand the process and perhaps it may help with your own frustration when you get feedback when your work is being edited. Sort of see it from a different perspective. Unless you’ve already done that. In that case disregard this message. lol Keep up the good work though. I did read your first chapter and was just waiting for it to go on sale so I can Kindle it. Hope to see more in the future!

  • http://www.facebook.com/people/Erik-Corr/100002915722983 Erik Corr

    Editing my novel now, very time consuming but Im close to being done!